HM Land Registry records the plot of land for 37, Benhilton Gardens, Sutton as measuring 440 m².

That makes it the 16th largest plot in the postcode, where 32 of the 36 other houses have recorded plot data.

37, Benhilton Gardens, Sutton has an Energy Performance Rating (EPC) of D. This is based on the most recent assessment, dated 13 Apr 2022.

The property is connected to mains gas and has fully double glazed windows. It is heated using a boiler and radiators (mains gas).

The most recent sale of 37, Benhilton Gardens, Sutton completed on 15th March 2024 at £580,000 and was recorded by HM Land Registry as a freehold house.

Since 1995 the property has sold twice.

Values of comparable properties have dropped by 7.2% over the period since March 2024.

• Sold Mar 2024£580,000
• Sold Dec 2015£535,000

Since 2010 55 properties similar to 37, Benhilton Gardens, Sutton have sold within a radius of 370 metres, per the Land Registry and our network of Estate Agents.

The latest, on the 3rd December 2025, was 45, Angel Hill, Sutton, SM1 3EH, a freehold house which sold for £400,000.

Read more about house prices in SM1.

• Sold Dec 2025£400,000 | 3 Bed House45, Angel Hill, Sutton, SM1 3EH45, Angel Hill, Sutton, SM1 3EH
• Sold Jan 2025£473,200 | 3 Bed House10, Sorrento Road, Sutton, SM1 1QU10, Sorrento Road, Sutton, SM1 1QU
• Sold Nov 2024£505,000 | 3 Bed House35, Benhilton Gardens, Sutton, SM1 3BS35, Benhilton Gardens, Sutton, SM1 3BS
• Sold Aug 2024£525,000 | 3 Bed House41, Rectory Road, Sutton, SM1 1QW41, Rectory Road, Sutton, SM1 1QW
• Sold Nov 2023£440,000 | 3 Bed House14, Sorrento Road, Sutton, SM1 1QU14, Sorrento Road, Sutton, SM1 1QU
• Sold Aug 2023£505,000 | 3 Bed House33B, All Saints Road, Sutton, SM1 3DG33B, All Saints Road, Sutton, SM1 3DG
• Sold Jul 2023£464,000 | 3 Bed House27, Hallmead Road, Sutton, SM1 1RD27, Hallmead Road, Sutton, SM1 1RD
• Sold Jun 2022£412,500 | 3 Bed House25, Stayton Road, Sutton, SM1 1QY25, Stayton Road, Sutton, SM1 1QY
• Sold Jan 2022£435,000 | 3 Bed House12, Hunting Gate Mews, Sutton, SM1 3DD12, Hunting Gate Mews, Sutton, SM1 3DD
• Sold Dec 2021£630,000 | 3 Bed House44, Hallmead Road, Sutton, SM1 1RD44, Hallmead Road, Sutton, SM1 1RD
• Sold Jun 2021£410,000 | 3 Bed House9, Stayton Road, Sutton, SM1 1QY9, Stayton Road, Sutton, SM1 1QY
• Sold May 2021£541,000 | 3 Bed House15, Benhilton Gardens, Sutton, SM1 3BS15, Benhilton Gardens, Sutton, SM1 3BS
• Sold Mar 2021£425,000 | 3 Bed House41A, Benhilton Gardens, Sutton, SM1 3BS41A, Benhilton Gardens, Sutton, SM1 3BS
• Sold Dec 2020£415,000 | 3 Bed House4, Stayton Road, Sutton, SM1 1RB4, Stayton Road, Sutton, SM1 1RB
• Sold Sep 2019£445,000 | 3 Bed House23, Vermont Road, Sutton, SM1 3EQ23, Vermont Road, Sutton, SM1 3EQ
• Sold Nov 2018£420,000 | 3 Bed House25, Vermont Road, Sutton, SM1 3EQ25, Vermont Road, Sutton, SM1 3EQ
• Sold Jan 2016£415,000 | 3 Bed House22, Benhilton Gardens, Sutton, SM1 3BS22, Benhilton Gardens, Sutton, SM1 3BS
• Sold Jun 2014£299,950 | 3 Bed House26, Stayton Road, Sutton, SM1 1RB26, Stayton Road, Sutton, SM1 1RB
• Sold May 2012£320,000 | 3 Bed House34, Benhilton Gardens, Sutton, SM1 3BS34, Benhilton Gardens, Sutton, SM1 3BS
• Sold Dec 2010£232,000 | 3 Bed House39, Ashleigh Gardens, Sutton, SM1 3EL39, Ashleigh Gardens, Sutton, SM1 3EL

Of the 43 addresses on Benhilton Gardens, Sutton, SM1, 37, Benhilton Gardens, Sutton comes out as the 31st largest and the 31st most expensive in our analysis of the public data.

It is also £89k more expensive than the average property across the SM1 district.

• All Saints Benhilton CofE Primary School

  100 m away
• Robin Hood Junior School

  700 m away
• Westbourne Primary School

  800 m away

• Sutton Grammar School

  700 m away
• Greenshaw High School

  800 m away
• Glenthorne High School

  1.3 km away

• Sutton Common

  |

  600 m away
• West Sutton

  |

  1.0 km away
• Sutton (London)

  |

  1.3 km away

The flood risk here is rated Very Low, based on Environment Agency data.