58, Benhill Avenue, Sutton occupies a 517 m² plot as recorded by HM Land Registry.

Of the 5 other houses in this postcode, 4 have recorded plot sizes, and this one ranks as the largest.

58, Benhill Avenue, Sutton has an Energy Performance Rating (EPC) of E. This is based on the most recent assessment, dated 11 Feb 2009.

The property is connected to mains gas and has partial double glazing. It is heated using a boiler and underfloor heating (mains gas).

58, Benhill Avenue, Sutton last changed hands on 23rd October 2009, selling for £373,950. The transaction was logged as a freehold house by HM Land Registry.

In total it has sold twice since 1995.

The market for similar properties has risen by 106.4% since October 2009.

• Sold Oct 2009£373,950
• Sold Apr 1997£115,000

Land Registry records and our Estate Agent network show 41 sales of comparable properties within 350 metres of 58, Benhill Avenue, Sutton since 2012.

Most recently, 37, Warwick Road, Sutton, SM1 4AP, a freehold house, sold at £436,000 on the 10th September 2025.

Read more about house prices in SM1.

• Sold Sep 2025£436,000 | 4 Bed House37, Warwick Road, Sutton, SM1 4AP37, Warwick Road, Sutton, SM1 4AP
• Sold Mar 2025£670,000 | 4 Bed House22, Lenham Road, Sutton, SM1 4AG22, Lenham Road, Sutton, SM1 4AG
• Sold Nov 2024£610,000 | 4 Bed House26, Manor Lane, Sutton, SM1 4AR26, Manor Lane, Sutton, SM1 4AR
• Sold Aug 2024£588,000 | 4 Bed House105, Benhill Avenue, Sutton, SM1 4DJ105, Benhill Avenue, Sutton, SM1 4DJ
• Sold Mar 2024£635,000 | 4 Bed House73, Lenham Road, Sutton, SM1 4BG73, Lenham Road, Sutton, SM1 4BG
• Sold Dec 2023£569,000 | 4 Bed House28, Manor Lane, Sutton, SM1 4AR28, Manor Lane, Sutton, SM1 4AR
• Sold Oct 2023£635,000 | 4 Bed House12, Lenham Road, Sutton, SM1 4AG12, Lenham Road, Sutton, SM1 4AG
• Sold Oct 2022£525,000 | 4 Bed House14, Myrtle Road, Sutton, SM1 4BX14, Myrtle Road, Sutton, SM1 4BX
• Sold Jul 2022£750,000 | 4 Bed House2, Litchfield Road, Sutton, SM1 4BQ2, Litchfield Road, Sutton, SM1 4BQ
• Sold Jul 2022£610,500 | 4 Bed House72, Warwick Road, Sutton, SM1 4BL72, Warwick Road, Sutton, SM1 4BL
• Sold Jun 2021£581,000 | 4 Bed House30, Manor Lane, Sutton, SM1 4AR30, Manor Lane, Sutton, SM1 4AR
• Sold May 2021£630,000 | 4 Bed House6, Lenham Road, Sutton, SM1 4AG6, Lenham Road, Sutton, SM1 4AG
• Sold Jun 2020£605,000 | 4 Bed House40, Warwick Road, Sutton, SM1 4AP40, Warwick Road, Sutton, SM1 4AP
• Sold Jan 2020£500,000 | 4 Bed House4, Clinton Terrace, Sutton, SM1 4BS4, Clinton Terrace, Sutton, SM1 4BS
• Sold Mar 2018£440,000 | 4 Bed House8, Clinton Terrace, Sutton, SM1 4BS8, Clinton Terrace, Sutton, SM1 4BS
• Sold Oct 2016£500,000 | 4 Bed House90, Benhill Avenue, Sutton, SM1 4DL90, Benhill Avenue, Sutton, SM1 4DL
• Sold Feb 2016£449,000 | 4 Bed House84, Benhill Avenue, Sutton, SM1 4DL84, Benhill Avenue, Sutton, SM1 4DL
• Sold Feb 2016£530,000 | 4 Bed House59, Lenham Road, Sutton, SM1 4BG59, Lenham Road, Sutton, SM1 4BG
• Sold Jul 2013£385,000 | 4 Bed House30, Lenham Road, Sutton, SM1 4AG30, Lenham Road, Sutton, SM1 4AG
• Sold Feb 2012£362,000 | 4 Bed House75, Warwick Road, Sutton, SM1 4BL75, Warwick Road, Sutton, SM1 4BL

Our analysis of the public data ranks 58, Benhill Avenue, Sutton as the 8th largest and the 2nd most expensive of the 189 addresses on Benhill Avenue, Sutton, SM1.

Against the SM1 postcode district average, it is £226k more expensive than the typical property.

• Manor Park Primary Academy

  300 m away
• Robin Hood Junior School

  400 m away
• All Saints Benhilton CofE Primary School

  700 m away

• Sutton Grammar School

  200 m away
• Greenshaw High School

  1.2 km away
• St Philomena's Catholic High School for Girls

  1.4 km away

• Sutton (London)

  |

  800 m away
• West Sutton

  |

  1.0 km away
• Sutton Common

  |

  1.1 km away

Environment Agency data suggests this area has a Very Low risk of flooding.