5, Cotleigh Gardens, Sheffield occupies a 235 m² plot as recorded by HM Land Registry.

Of the 16 other houses in this postcode, 14 have recorded plot sizes, and this one ranks as the 14th largest.

5, Cotleigh Gardens, Sheffield last changed hands on 4th April 2014, selling for £107,500. The transaction was logged as a freehold house by HM Land Registry.

In total it has sold 3 times since 1995.

The market for similar properties has risen by 93.8% since April 2014.

• Sold Apr 2014£107,500
• Sold Jun 2005£89,950
• Sold Nov 2004£72,000

Land Registry records and our Estate Agent network show 168 sales of comparable properties within 530 metres of 5, Cotleigh Gardens, Sheffield since 2019.

Most recently, 17, Cotleigh Avenue, Sheffield, S12 4HQ, a freehold house, sold at £200,000 on the 24th April 2026.

Read more about house prices in S12.

• Sold Apr 2026£200,000 | 3 Bed House17, Cotleigh Avenue, Sheffield, S12 4HQ17, Cotleigh Avenue, Sheffield, S12 4HQ
• Sold Dec 2025£190,000 | 3 Bed House35, Spa View Road, Sheffield, S12 4HE35, Spa View Road, Sheffield, S12 4HE
• Sold Feb 2025£179,500 | 3 Bed House21, Spring Water Avenue, Sheffield, S12 4HJ21, Spring Water Avenue, Sheffield, S12 4HJ
• Sold Oct 2024£180,000 | 3 Bed House8, Spring Water Avenue, Sheffield, S12 4HJ8, Spring Water Avenue, Sheffield, S12 4HJ
• Sold Aug 2024£175,000 | 3 Bed House3, Spa View Road, Sheffield, S12 4HE3, Spa View Road, Sheffield, S12 4HE
• Sold May 2024£150,000 | 3 Bed House18, Cotleigh Drive, Sheffield, S12 4HU18, Cotleigh Drive, Sheffield, S12 4HU
• Sold Mar 2024£160,000 | 3 Bed House25, Cotleigh Avenue, Sheffield, S12 4HQ25, Cotleigh Avenue, Sheffield, S12 4HQ
• Sold Feb 2024£197,500 | 3 Bed House4, Spring Water Avenue, Sheffield, S12 4HJ4, Spring Water Avenue, Sheffield, S12 4HJ
• Sold Dec 2023£170,000 | 3 Bed House8, Cotleigh Drive, Sheffield, S12 4HU8, Cotleigh Drive, Sheffield, S12 4HU
• Sold Nov 2023£160,000 | 3 Bed House15, Cotleigh Gardens, Sheffield, S12 4HW15, Cotleigh Gardens, Sheffield, S12 4HW
• Sold Jun 2023£145,000 | 3 Bed House35, Cotleigh Drive, Sheffield, S12 4HU35, Cotleigh Drive, Sheffield, S12 4HU
• Sold Jun 2023£136,000 | 4 Bed House17, Cotleigh Road, Sheffield, S12 4HY17, Cotleigh Road, Sheffield, S12 4HY
• Sold May 2023£162,500 | 3 Bed House46, Spa View Place, Sheffield, S12 4HD46, Spa View Place, Sheffield, S12 4HD
• Sold Apr 2023£153,315 | 3 Bed House45, Birley Spa Lane, Sheffield, S12 4EB45, Birley Spa Lane, Sheffield, S12 4EB
• Sold Jan 2023£163,000 | 3 Bed House35, Cotleigh Road, Sheffield, S12 4HY35, Cotleigh Road, Sheffield, S12 4HY
• Sold Jun 2022£185,600 | 3 Bed House15, Spring Water Avenue, Sheffield, S12 4HJ15, Spring Water Avenue, Sheffield, S12 4HJ
• Sold Mar 2022£140,000 | 3 Bed House26, Spring Water Drive, Sheffield, S12 4HP26, Spring Water Drive, Sheffield, S12 4HP
• Sold Jun 2020£125,000 | 3 Bed House24, Spring Water Drive, Sheffield, S12 4HP24, Spring Water Drive, Sheffield, S12 4HP
• Sold Apr 2020£130,000 | 3 Bed House1, Spa View Road, Sheffield, S12 4HE1, Spa View Road, Sheffield, S12 4HE
• Sold Nov 2019£123,000 | 3 Bed House19, Cotleigh Avenue, Sheffield, S12 4HQ19, Cotleigh Avenue, Sheffield, S12 4HQ

Our analysis of the public data ranks 5, Cotleigh Gardens, Sheffield as the 4th largest and the 3rd most expensive of the 16 addresses on Cotleigh Gardens, Sheffield, S12.

Against the S12 postcode district average, it is £19k less expensive than the typical property.

• St John Fisher Primary, A Catholic Voluntary Academy

  100 m away
• Birley Spa Primary Academy

  500 m away
• Rainbow Forge Primary Academy

  1.0 km away

• The Birley Academy

  1.5 km away
• Outwood Academy City

  1.6 km away
• Handsworth Grange Community Sports College

  2.7 km away

• Woodhouse

  |

  2.6 km away
• Darnall

  |

  4.4 km away
• Sheffield

  |

  6.5 km away

Environment Agency data suggests this area has a Very Low risk of flooding.