2, Old Hay Gardens, Sheffield occupies a 417 m² plot as recorded by HM Land Registry.

Of the 11 other houses in this postcode, 10 have recorded plot sizes, and this one ranks as the 8th largest.

2, Old Hay Gardens, Sheffield last changed hands on 16th May 2008, selling for £499,077. The transaction was logged as a freehold house by HM Land Registry.

That is its only recorded sale since 1995.

The market for similar properties has risen by 54.4% since May 2008.

• Sold May 2008£499,077

Land Registry records and our Estate Agent network show 94 sales of comparable properties within 920 metres of 2, Old Hay Gardens, Sheffield since 2009.

Most recently, 21, Saxon Avenue, Sheffield, S17 3SB, a leasehold house, sold at £590,000 on the 16th February 2026.

Read more about house prices in S17.

• Sold Feb 2026£590,000 | 4 Bed House21, Saxon Avenue, Sheffield, S17 3SB21, Saxon Avenue, Sheffield, S17 3SB
• Sold Jan 2026£735,000 | 5 Bed House27, Durvale Court, Sheffield, S17 3PT27, Durvale Court, Sheffield, S17 3PT
• Sold Aug 2025£701,510 | 4 Bed House8, Overdale Gardens, Sheffield, S17 3HE8, Overdale Gardens, Sheffield, S17 3HE
• Sold Aug 2025£800,000 | 4 Bed House16, Old Hay Gardens, Sheffield, S17 3HG16, Old Hay Gardens, Sheffield, S17 3HG
• Sold Nov 2024£832,500 | 4 Bed House78, Church Lane, Sheffield, S17 3GT78, Church Lane, Sheffield, S17 3GT
• Sold Nov 2024£844,000 | 5 Bed House47, Durvale Court, Sheffield, S17 3PT47, Durvale Court, Sheffield, S17 3PT
• Sold Aug 2024£605,000 | 4 Bed House29, Saxon Avenue, Sheffield, S17 3SB29, Saxon Avenue, Sheffield, S17 3SB
• Sold Mar 2024£722,500 | 5 Bed House8, Old Hay Gardens, Sheffield, S17 3HG8, Old Hay Gardens, Sheffield, S17 3HG
• Sold Jun 2023£705,000 | 5 Bed House3, High Trees, Sheffield, S17 3GF3, High Trees, Sheffield, S17 3GF
• Sold Apr 2023£850,000 | 4 Bed House3, Overdale Gardens, Sheffield, S17 3HE3, Overdale Gardens, Sheffield, S17 3HE
• Sold Jan 2022£779,000 | 5 Bed House4, Old Hay Gardens, Sheffield, S17 3HG4, Old Hay Gardens, Sheffield, S17 3HG
• Sold Dec 2021£690,000 | 5 Bed House10, High Trees, Sheffield, S17 3GF10, High Trees, Sheffield, S17 3GF
• Sold Apr 2021£650,000 | 4 Bed House4, Middlefield Close, Sheffield, S17 3AR4, Middlefield Close, Sheffield, S17 3AR
• Sold Mar 2021£670,000 | 4 Bed House89, Townhead Road, Sheffield, S17 3GE89, Townhead Road, Sheffield, S17 3GE
• Sold Mar 2020£567,500 | 5 Bed House98, Bushey Wood Road, Sheffield, S17 3QD98, Bushey Wood Road, Sheffield, S17 3QD
• Sold Jan 2020£750,000 | 4 Bed House6, Blacka Moor View, Sheffield, S17 3GZ6, Blacka Moor View, Sheffield, S17 3GZ
• Sold Dec 2019£745,000 | 4 Bed House76, Church Lane, Sheffield, S17 3GT76, Church Lane, Sheffield, S17 3GT
• Sold Nov 2019£725,000 | 5 Bed House103, Furniss Avenue, Sheffield, S17 3QN103, Furniss Avenue, Sheffield, S17 3QN
• Sold Dec 2017£625,000 | 5 Bed House134, Furniss Avenue, Sheffield, S17 3QP134, Furniss Avenue, Sheffield, S17 3QP
• Sold Nov 2009£475,000 | 4 Bed House22, Old Hay Gardens, Sheffield, S17 3HG22, Old Hay Gardens, Sheffield, S17 3HG

Our analysis of the public data ranks 2, Old Hay Gardens, Sheffield as the 7th largest and the 6th most expensive of the 11 addresses on Old Hay Gardens, Sheffield, S17.

Against the S17 postcode district average, it is £289k more expensive than the typical property.

• Dore Primary School

  500 m away
• Totley All Saints Church of England Voluntary Aided Primary School

  800 m away
• Totley Primary School

  1.0 km away

• King Ecgbert School

  600 m away
• Silverdale School

  3.4 km away
• High Storrs School

  4.2 km away

• Dore & Totley

  |

  2.0 km away
• Dronfield

  |

  5.6 km away
• Grindleford

  |

  5.7 km away

Environment Agency data suggests this area has a Very Low risk of flooding.