Stay up to date
Stay up to date
Bricks&Logic is a trading name of Urban Markets Ltd
Company No. 11113204
  | Â
VAT No. GB 287 0845 68
Registered Address: 2 Leman St, London E1 8FA
Estate Agents active nearby!
What's this?
Be the first Estate
Agent here!
Old Hay LaneHouse Prices / Yorkshire and The Humber, Sheffield
Last updated Jun 2026
Key Street Insights
Old Hay Lane is a residential street with 19 addresses.
It ranks as the 124th largest and 207th most expensive of the 238 streets in the S17 area. The dominant property type is a modern house built after 1980.
The street contains a total of 19 properties: 17 houses and 2 flats.
19
Properties
- Houses
- Flats
Key Street Insights
Old Hay Lane is a residential street with 19 addresses.
It ranks as the 124th largest and 207th most expensive of the 238 streets in the S17 area. The dominant property type is a modern house built after 1980.
The street contains a total of 19 properties: 17 houses and 2 flats.
19
Properties
- Houses
- Flats
Get a Fast Offer
for your property
Get a Mortgage
or re-mortgage
House Priceson Old Hay Lane
Sale prices range from £139,114 for 1 bedroom Leasehold flats (204 ft2) to £1,877,050 for 5 bedroom freehold houses with a garden (3,132 ft2) .
Monthly rental prices range from £618 pcm for 1 bed flats to £5,741 pcm for 5 bed houses.
The gross rental yield is between 3.6% and 5.3%.
The average value per square foot is £599.
Average Sale Value
£804,128
Average Rental Value
£2,598 pcm
Average Rental Yield
3.9% /year
Average Value Per Sqft
£599 /ft2
Sales Market Trendson Old Hay Lane
The last sale on Old Hay Lane sold for £1,200,000 on 12th March 2026. Since then prices are down an average of 0.1%.
The current average value in the street is £804,128.
The Old Hay Lane Sales Market has increased by 37.8% over the last 10 years.
| Period | Year on Year | Average Price |
|---|---|---|
| May 2026 | 0.7% | £804,128 |
| May 2025 | -1% | £798,369 |
| May 2024 | 0% | £806,066 |
| May 2023 | 1.6% | £806,207 |
| May 2022 | 14.8% | £793,823 |
| May 2021 | 5.8% | £691,385 |
| May 2020 | 1.9% | £653,407 |
| May 2019 | 5.3% | £641,420 |
| May 2018 | 2.2% | £608,884 |
| May 2017 | 2.1% | £595,518 |
| May 2016 | 10.3% | £583,529 |
| May 2015 | 3.5% | £529,242 |
| May 2014 | 7% | £511,507 |
| May 2013 | -1.9% | £478,200 |
| May 2012 | 0.2% | £487,556 |
| May 2011 | 4% | £486,649 |
| May 2010 | 8.6% | £467,965 |
| May 2009 | -10.3% | £430,711 |
| May 2008 | 0% | £480,045 |
| May 2007 | 0% | £479,882 |
Rental Market Trendson Old Hay Lane
The current average rental value in the street is £2,598.
The Old Hay Lane Rental Market has increased by 52.0% over the last 10 years.
| Period | Year on Year | Average Price |
|---|---|---|
| May 2026 | 2.6% | £2,598pcm |
| May 2025 | 3.1% | £2,531pcm |
| May 2024 | 6.8% | £2,455pcm |
| May 2023 | 7.5% | £2,299pcm |
| May 2022 | 8.1% | £2,140pcm |
| May 2021 | 8.3% | £1,979pcm |
| May 2020 | 2.1% | £1,827pcm |
| May 2019 | -0.3% | £1,790pcm |
| May 2018 | 2.1% | £1,796pcm |
| May 2017 | 2.9% | £1,758pcm |
| May 2016 | 1.5% | £1,709pcm |
| May 2015 | 2.6% | £1,683pcm |
| May 2014 | 1.6% | £1,641pcm |
| May 2013 | 1% | £1,614pcm |
| May 2012 | -0.1% | £1,599pcm |
| May 2011 | 2.8% | £1,601pcm |
| May 2010 | 5% | £1,558pcm |
| May 2009 | -5.3% | £1,483pcm |
| May 2008 | 1.8% | £1,566pcm |
| May 2007 | 0% | £1,538pcm |
Properties and Buildingson Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17
- Avenue Farm, Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17 3AT5 bed modern house
- Broadstorth, Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17Building2 units
- Fall Cottage, Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17 3AT5 bed period house
- Old Hay, Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17 3AT5 bed period house
- Old Hay Cottage, Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17 3AT5 bed modern house
- The Stables, The Elms, Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17 3GN3 bed period house
- The Lodge, Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17 3GN3 bed period house
- The Nook, Avenue Farm, Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17 3AT5 bed mid-century house
- The Old Mill, Avenue Farm, Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17 3AT5 bed modern house
- Tree Tops, Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17 3AT4 bed modern house
- 1, Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17 3GN5 bed modern house
- 3, Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17 3GN3 bed mid-century house
- 5, Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17 3GN3 bed mid-century house
- 6, Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17 3GN
- 7, Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17 3GN4 bed mid-century house
- 8, Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17 3GN
- 10, Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17 3GN3 bed mid-century house
- 12, Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17 3GN
Sales Historyon Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17
The last sale was on 12th March 2026 for £1,200,000 and since then the market in the area has decreased by 0.1%. The street has had a total of 14 sales since 1995.
Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17 has seen 3 sales in the last three years and 2 sales in the last twelve months.
Sold Mar 2026£1,200,000 | 4 Bed HouseOld Hay LaneTree Tops, Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17 3AT
Sold Jul 2025£687,500 | 3 Bed HouseOld Hay Lane10, Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17 3GN
Sold Sep 2024£2,110,000 | 5 Bed HouseOld Hay LaneOld Hay, Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17 3AT
Sold Dec 2022£585,000 | 4 Bed HouseOld Hay Lane7, Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17 3GN
Sold Feb 2020£990,000 | 5 Bed HouseOld Hay LaneFall Cottage, Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17 3AT
Sold Oct 2015£279,950 | 3 Bed HouseOld Hay Lane3, Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17 3GN
Sold Feb 2014£267,000 | 3 Bed HouseOld Hay Lane5, Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17 3GN
Sold Jun 2010£390,000 | 3 Bed HouseOld Hay Lane10, Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17 3GN
Sold Feb 2010£299,950 | 4 Bed HouseOld Hay Lane7, Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17 3GN
Sold May 2007£1,700,000 | 4 Bed HouseOld Hay LaneTree Tops, Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17 3AT
Sold Jul 2003£210,000 | 5 Bed HouseOld Hay Lane1, Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17 3GN
Sold Jan 2002£140,000 | 3 Bed HouseOld Hay Lane5, Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17 3GN
Sold Nov 2001£144,200 | 3 Bed HouseOld Hay Lane3, Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17 3GN
Sold May 1997£113,000 | 3 Bed HouseOld Hay Lane10, Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17 3GN
Top 3 Most Expensive Saleson Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17
Nearby Streetsto Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17
Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17 is the 124th largest and the 207th most expensive street in the S17 area.
- 92 mOld Hay Gardens, Sheffield, S1711 Addresses
- 188 mBlacka Moor Crescent, Sheffield, S1720 Addresses
- 204 mOld Hay Close, Sheffield, S1766 Addresses
- 263 mBlacka Moor Road, Sheffield, S1733 Addresses
- 305 mOverdale Rise, Sheffield, S175 Addresses
- 311 mTotley Brook Glen, Sheffield, S1721 Addresses
Postcodeson Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17
There are 2 postcodes on Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17.
- House prices in S17 3GN10 Addresses
- House prices in S17 3AT9 Addresses
Property Typesin Old Hay Lane
- 4 period houses built between 1800 and 1911
- 5 modern houses built after 1980
- 2 modern flats built after 1980
- 5 mid-century houses built between 1936 and 1979
- 3 other addresses of unknown type
- period house (4)
- modern house (5)
- modern flat (2)
- mid-century house (5)
- Unknown (3)
Energy Efficiencyof properties on Old Hay Lane
- Energy Performance Certificate (EPC) surveys conducted for 14 properties.
- The dominant rating is C.
- A (0)
- E (5)
- B (1)
- F (0)
- C (5)
- G (0)
- D (3)
- No EPC (5)
Schools Nearby
The nearest primary school to Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17 is Dore Primary School, which is 500 metres away.
- 500mDore Primary School
- 700mTotley All Saints Church of England Voluntary Aided Primary School
- 900mTotley Primary School
The nearest secondary school is King Ecgbert School, which is 500 metres away.
- 500mKing Ecgbert School
- 3.4kmSilverdale School
- 4.2kmHigh Storrs School
More reading links
Public Transport Nearby
The closest station to Old Hay Lane, Sheffield, S17 is Dore & Totley station, which is 2.0 kilometres away.
- 2.0kmDore & Totley
- 5.4kmDronfield
- 5.8kmGrindleford
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
Loading...
